Gardeners Cricket Club
Gardeners Cricket Club

Tuesday, 1 October, CXIs v Mar, in space


I don’t know what you’ve made of the preceding verbiage, but the real fantasy cricket begins (and ends) here. That’s Mar as in Mars in the title, and the C represents County, as in the composite county XIs to play Mars, home and away, I guess, with the players picked on the basis of the performances I’ve seen. You’d imagine the Martian track to be as slow and surly as the one that has helped to condemn Surrey to division two. So the first-class team to play in the warm-for-October weather we had then – probably a bit chillier on Mars, mind, like UAE minus the camels – assumes a turning pitch.


The strategy, in true sub-continental fashion, is to field first, bat once, and spin them out in the third innings. Onions wasn’t playing in the Durham game at the Oval so he’s ineligible; Rushworth didn’t do enough. Sidebottom came close, but Barker, playing at Guildford, offers a more all-round game, and runs on the board are crucial. Alfonso Thomas might have been chosen, but Surrey homeboy Tim Linley has to be in there to bowl the hard yards. Patel and Rayner are the main spinners, with Borthwick in the Jadeja role, if more expensively. Buckley deserves a mention. Amla pips Ponting as the overseas player. Punter may or may not like the joke of being 12th man. Collingwood is there because – as he proved so well – captaincy matters. And he could offer a few overs. Davies picks himself.


Sibley SUR

Wells SUS

Amla SUR

Joyce SUS

Collingwood DUR (capt)

Borthwick DUR

Davies SUR (wkt)

Barker WAR

Rayner MID

Linley SUR

Patel MID


12th man/player coach: Ponting SUR


Only three sides to pick from for the limited-overs team, but three handy one-day sides all the same. This XI (everyone, bar Davies, can bowl) would play any T20 fixture, too. Wood gets the nod over Napier, by virtue of Hampshire bias and his left-handedness. Pace-off-the-ball would be a regular tactic.


Carberry HAM

Davies SUR (wkt)

Vince HAM

Bopara ESS

Ten Doeschate ESS

Dawson HAM

Mascarenhas HAM (capt)

Wood HAM

Ansari SUR

Batty SUR

Topley ESS


12th man/player coach: Solanki SUR


Postscript: Surrey will be sorry enough after this season, but I can’t resist marks out of 10. Not to rub it in, rather to rank what I saw. Taking all formats into account, here goes: 10 Sibley 9 Ponting, Amla 8 Davies 7 Solanki 6 Burns, Ansari, Dernbach, Linley 5 Meaker, O’Brien 4 Batty, Smith, Tremlett, Harinath, Wilson, Roy 3 Keedy, Lewis 2 De Bruyn, Curran 1 Jewell

   Want to get        involved?

We play most of our games in Dulwich and net during the winter at The Oval.  Send us an email at


Follow GCC

  2023 Members


Oliver Cunningham (life)

Jamie Elliott (life)

Ludo Hunter-Tilney

John Lloyd (life)

Hugo Nisbet (life)

Steven Seaton

David Woodhouse (life)

Caveat lector

All our match reports and player profiles are written by third parties,

and may involve some poetic licence. GCC cannot be held liable for any misrepresentation in these articles.

Print | Sitemap
© Gardeners Cricket Club

This website was created using IONOS MyWebsite.